A rapid reporter assay for recombinant human brain natriuretic peptide(rhBNP)by GloSensor technology

Lei Yu,Xinchng Shi,Chunmei Hn,Chunming Ro,?,Junzhi Wng,b,??

aNational Institutes for Food and Drug Control,Beijing 100050,China

bWHO Collaboration Centre for Biologicals Standardization and Evaluation,Beijing 100050,China

Keywords:RhBNP cGMP GloSensor technology Reporter assay

A B S T R A C T Accurate determination of biological activity is essential in quality control of recombinant human brain natriuretic peptide(rhBNP).In previous study,we successfully developed a genetically modified cell line 293GCAC3-based ELISA assay for rhBNP.But ELISA procedure is still tedious,so this study was aimed to develop a rapid and simple bioassay for rhBNP using GloSensor technology,which provides a platform of flexible luciferase-based biosensors for real-time detection of signaling events in live cells,including cGMP production.A reporter cell line 293GCAGlo-G1 was constructed by transfecting pGloSensor?40F plasmid into 293GCAC3.The reporter assay based on 293GCAGlo-G1 showed high precision with intraassay CV being 8.3%and inter-assay CV being 14.1%;high accuracy with 80%,100%and 120%recovery rate being 99.2%,102.4%and 99.0%respectively;and great linearity with R2of linear fitting equation being 0.99.Besides,no significant difference was found in test results of reporter assay and 293GCAC3-based ELISA assay(paired t test,p=0.630).All these results suggested that the reporter assay was a viable assay for biological determination of rhBNP.

1.Introduction

B-type natriuretic peptide(BNP),also called brain natriuretic peptide,is produced primarily by the ventricular myocardium in response to volume and pressure overload[1–3].Recombinant human B-type natriuretic peptide(rhBNP)was approved by FDA in 2001 to treat severe congestive heart failure and recommended in the acute decompensated heart failure(ADHF)treatment guidelines by the European Society of Cardiology(ESC)in 2005[4–6].It also obtained a China national new drug certificate and production license in 2005.It can mediate natriuretic,diuretic and smooth muscle relaxant effects,and thus decrease in preload and afterload by venous and arterial vasodilation,which results in increased cardiac output[7–9].A recent clinical study found that continuous administration of rhBNP can improve heart and renal function in patients after cardiopulmonary bypass surgery as well as accelerate the recovery from myocardial injury[10].

As rhBNP is used more and more widely in clinic,it is imperative to improve the quality standards of relevant pharmaceutical products.In previous study,we developed a 293GCAC3 cell-based ELISA assay to replace rabbit aortic strips test(RAST),which simplifies the experiment and improves accuracy and precision,and this cell-based assay has been widely applied within the industry in China[11].But ELISA procedure is still very tedious,with repeated washing of plate,which surely would bring variation in measurements.Besides,since the concentration of different batches of commercial anti-cGMP antibodies and HRP-cGMP is not uniform,the dilution rates of working solutions need to be reconfirmed by pre-experiments when new batches of reagents are used.Here we introduce a rapid bioassay for rhBNP using GloSensor technology,which provides a platform of flexible luciferase-based biosensors for real-time detection of signaling events in live cells,including cAMP,cGMP and protease activity.pGloSensor?cGMP(Promega)uses genetically encoded biosensor variant with cGMP binding domain fused to mutant form of Photinus pyralis luciferase[12,13].Upon binding to cGMP,conformational changes occur,promoting large increases in light output.The magnitude of the luminescence increase is directly proportional to the amount of rhBNP.This Glo-Sensor technology was developed ten years ago and primarily applied in research on cellular signaling mechanism in the past few years.This is the first time for this technology to be used in bioactivity determination of bio-drugs,and our study provides a new way to detect agonists of guanylate cyclase/adenylate cyclase receptors and G protein-coupled receptors.

In this study we developed a reporter cell line 293GCAGlo-G1 by transfecting the plasmid pGloSensor?cGMP into 293GCAC3 cells,which could produce increased light output to rhBNP stimulation.A reporter assay based on 293GCAGlo-G1 was subsequently established and validated,as well as compared with 293GCAC3 cell-based ELISA assay.

2.Materials and methods

2.1.Materials

293GCAC3 cell line was constructed by National Institute for the Control of Pharmaceutical and Biological Products,Beijing,China.DMEM-high glucose,fetal calf serum,0.25%trypsin-EDTA and G418 were from Thermo Fisher Scientific(Waltham,MA,USA).GloSensor? cAMP reagent and pGloSensor? 40F plasmid were from Promega(Madison,Wisconsin,USA).X-transgene 9 transfection reagent was from Roche(Basel,Switzerland).Hygromycin B was from Amresco(Englewood,Colorado,USA).3-Isobutyl-1-Methylxanthine(IBMX)wasfrom Sigma-Aldrich(Stockholm,Sweden).rhBNP reference(500 units per vial)and rhBNP samples were supplied by manufacturers(China).

2.2.Cell culture,transfection and clone selection

2.2.1.Cell culture

293GCAC3 cells were grown in DMEM-high glucose supplemented with 10%fetal calf serum and 200μg/mL G418.Cell passaging was achieved by detaching the cells in 0.25%trypsin-EDTA and splitting the cells every 3 days.

2.2.2.Transfection

293GCAC3 cells(approximately 80%confluence)in 6-well plate were transfected with the plasmid using X-transgene 9 transfection reagent according to the protocol.After cultured in growth media for 48h,cells were collected for next test.

2.2.3.Clone selection

293GCAC3 cells transfected with pGloSensor?40F were cultured in growth media for 48 h.Then the growth media was replaced with selective media containing 200μg/mL G418 and 100μg/mL hygromycin B.After growth in selective media for 4 weeks,resistant clones were subcloned by limited dilution and screened for the induction of light output by treatment of cells with gradient concentrations of rhBNP.The clone exhibiting the highest responsiveness to rhBNP was further characterized.

2.3.293GCAC3-based ELISA assay

293GCAC3 cells in DMEM without antibiotics and serum were seeded in 96-well costar plates(1.8×104/well in a total volume of 180 μL)and incubated at 37 °C in a CO2incubator for 16–18h.RhBNP reference or samples were gradiently diluted by 4 times in PBS buffer containing 1 mM IBMX and 0.1%BSA,and 20μL rhBNP serial dilutions were added to the cell plate,which was then incubated at 37 °C in a CO2incubator for 1.5–2h.Protein G precoated microtiter plate was incubated with 100μL cGMP antibodies for 1 h.50μL culture supernatant and 50μL HRP-cGMP conjugate were mixed,and put into cGMP antibody coated plate,shaking at room temperature for 3 h.Then the mixtures were discarded,and the plate was washed 4 times.100μL TMD substrates were put into the plate,reacting at room temperature for 10min,and terminated by 100μL stop buffer.OD450values were then determined by reading on a SPECTRAmax plate reader.

2.4.Reporter assay

293GCAGlo-G1 cells in analysis medium(IMDM supplemented with 10%fetal calf serum)were seeded in 96-well white plates(4×104/well in a total volume of 50 μL),and incubated at 37°C in a CO2incubator for 16–18 h.30μL equilibration medium(3 mL analysis medium supplemented with 200μL of GloSensor? cAMP reagent stock solution)was put into the cell plate and incubated at room temperature for 2h.rhBNP reference or samples was gradiently diluted 2 times in analysis medium,and 20μL rhBNP serial dilutions were added to the cell plate,which was then incubated at room temperature for 30–60 min.Luminescence values were determined by reading on a SPECTRAmax plate reader at set intervals.

2.5.Statistical analysis

Analyses of the data consisted of statistical models used to calculate EC50value as well as statistical techniques for method validation.In order to calculate the EC50values,dose response and linear range,we used the 4-PL model.Analyses were carried out using GraphPad Prism 5 and SigmaPlot 12 for EC50calculations and method validation.

3.Results

3.1.Responsiveness of 293GCAC3 transfected with pGloSensor?40F to rhBNP stimulation

As the initial step,we transiently transfected 293GCAC3 cells with the plasmid pGloSensor?40 F and tested whether it could produce increased light output to rhBNP stimulation.5h after transfection,equilibration medium was added and incubated at room temperature for 2 h,followed by rhBNP stimulation(serial concentrations)for 90 min and the light output was detected at set intervals.The results are shown in Fig.1.The results indicated that pGloSensor?40F transfected 293GCAC3 cells produced increased levels of light output in response to the ascending concentrations of rhBNP,and the increase of light output was the highest between 30 and 40 min.As the cells transiently transfected with pGlo-Sensor 40 F demonstrated excellent responsiveness to rhBNP treatment,we then set out to develop a stable reporter cell line.

Fig.1.Responsiveness of 293GCAC3 transfected with pGloSensor 40F to rhBNP stimulation.293GCAC3 cells transfected with pGloSensor 40F were stimulated by rhBNP dilutions and the light output was determined at set intervals(5,10,15,20,25,30,40,60 and 90 min).Each point and error bar represents the mean and standard deviation of three replicates,respectively.

Fig.2.The effect of IBMX on the reporter assay.293GCAGlo-G1 cells were stimulated by rhBNP dilutions with or without the presence of IBMX(1 mM).Each point and error bar represents the mean and standard deviation of two replicates,respectively.

3.2.Development of a reporter assay for rhBNP

293GCAC3 cells were transfected with pGloSensor?40F,and cultured in selective media containing 100μg/mL hygromycin B for 4 weeks.Positive clones were obtained by limited dilution.As shown in Fig.S1,clone G1 was found to produce highest level of light output in response to rhBNP treatment,which was next employed to develop a reporter assay for rhBNP.Various parameters of the assay were optimized,including cell number(40,000 per well),concentration range of rhBNP(.002–0.25μg/mL),and stimulation time(30–40 min).Given the presence of IBMX,an inhibitor of phosphodiesterase(PDE),is essential in ELISA assay,we tested the influence of IBMX(1 mM)in this reporter assay.As shown in Fig.2,with the presence of IBMX,the magnitude and stability of light output improved slightly,but the background light output was significantly increased(about 3 times),which was against the accuracy and precision of the assay.So for the reporter assay,IBMX was unnecessary.The parameters of dose-response curves of 293GCAGlo-G1cells stimulated by rhBNP dilutions with or without the presence of IBMX are also listed in Table 1,including slope,minimum and maximum light outputs,EC50and R2.Although the light outputs changed over time,the EC50values were relatively stable(CV was 7.7%for IBMX-and 5.8%for IBMX+).

3.3.Precision,linearity,and accuracy

To validate the reporter assay,all tests were conducted according to ICH Guidelines,including precision,linearity,and a ccuracy.Five repeated analyses of rhBNP sample in one test or five different tests were conducted to evaluate intra-or interassay precision.Intra-assay CV was 8.3%and inter-assay CV was 14.1%,demonstrating high precision.Accuracy was evaluated by testing recovery rates,and the specific approach was that 80%,100%and 120%rhBNP references were mixed with 100%rhBNP sample and tested simultaneously.The recovery rate was represented by the percentage rate of the difference between measured value of mixture and measured value of 100%rhBNP sample to expected value of rhBNP reference in mixture.The 80%,100%and 120%recovery rates were 99.2%,102.4%and 99.0%respectively,demonstrating great accuracy of the assay.Linearity was evaluated by testing25%,50%,75%,100%and 125%of rhBNP samples,and the linear fitting equation(y=0.99x-0.01,R2=0.99)represents the correlation between them,where x is expected value and y is measured value.The slope of 0.99 suggested high correlations between expected values and measured values,and R2of 0.99 showed great linearity.

3.4.Comparison of reporter assay with ELISA assay

The agreement between reporter assay and ELISA assay was assessed by testing various samples using both methods.Three rhBNP bulks and three rhBNP products were tested by both methods,and the results are listed in Table 2.PairedTtest showed no significant difference between two methods(p=0.630),suggesting the consistency of two methods in test results.Then we compared two methods in materials,operation steps,sensitivity,signal to noise ratio(SNR)and precision(Table 3).The two methods were similar in sensitivity and precision,but the reporter assay was more rapid and simpler.

4.Discussion

Bioactivity determination is a critical quality attribute(CQA)for quality control of biological drugs,including rhBNP.The biological activity of this peptide drug was determined by RAST earlier,which is known to be laborious and time-consuming,with poor reproducibility and isolation of fresh aortic strip from sacrificed rabbit[14,15].Numerous attempts have been made over decades to develop alternative assays aiming at reduced use of animals and improved precision and robustness.The biological action of BNP is mediated by its main receptor natriuretic peptide receptor-A(NPR-A)/guanyl cyclase site(GC-A),which has a guanyl cyclase site.Activated GC-A receptor could catalyze the conversion of guanosine triphos-phate(GTP)to cyclic guanosine monophosphate(cGMP),a second messenger triggering potent physiologicalactions[16–19].Given the well-characterized pathwaysactivated by BNP,quantification of cGMP in cells exposed to rhBNP has been explored as attractive alternative assay.Indeed,several types of cGMP-involved assays for rhBNPs have been reported in recent years,including the measurement of cGMP in human umbilical vein endothelial cells(HUVEC)or PC12 cells by radioimmunoassay,as well as a modified cell line 293GCAC3 by ELISA assay,which was developed by our previous work[11].

Table 1.The parameters of dose-response curves of 293GCAGlo-G1 cells stimulated by rhBNP dilutions with or without the presence of IBMX.

Table 2.Test results of rhBNP samples by ELISA assay and reporter assay.

In this study,a new reporter assay was explored based on GloSensor technology,a platform technology of biosensors for the intracellular detection of signal transduction in living cells developed by Promega Corporation[13,14,20].The plasmid pGlo-Sensor?40F encodes a biosensor variant with cGMP binding domain fused to a mutant form of Photinus pyralis luciferase.Upon binding to cGMP,conformational changes occur,promoting large increases in light output.A reporter cell line was constructed by transfecting pGloSensor?40F into GCA-overexpressing cell line 293GCAC3.Fig.3 describes the principle of this new reporter assay.Method validation was conducted according to ICH Guidelines,including precision,linearity,and accuracy.The reporter assay showed high precision with intra-assay CV being 8.3%and inter-assay CV being 14.1%;high accuracy with 80%,100%and 120%recovery rate being 99.2%,102.4%and 99.0%respectively;and great linearity with R2of linear fitting equation being 0.99.Given the specificity of reporter assay was consistent with ELISA assay,which has been validated in former study[11],it is unnecessary to evaluate it again.Besides,no significant difference was found in results of reporter assay and 293GCAC3-based ELISA assay(pairedTtest,p=0.630).The two methods were similar on sensitivity and precision,but the reporter assay is more rapid and simpler for avoidance of ELISA steps.

5.Conclusion

Collectively,all our results suggested that the reporter assay was a viable assay for biological determination of rhBNP products,and single-reagent and one-step determination made the assay more controlled and suitable in routine inspection compared with former ELISA assay.What is more,our study provides a new way to detect agonists of guanylate cyclase/adenylate cyclase receptors and G protein-coupled receptors,which would promote the research and development(R&D)of these types of bio-drugs.

Table 3.Comparison between ELISA assay and reporter assay.

Fig.3.A sketch for the principle of new reporter assay.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

This work was financially supported by grants from the National Science and Technology Major Project (No.2015ZX09501008-001)and the Middle-aged and Young Development Research Foundation of NIFDC(No.2017B3).The funders had no role in study design,data collection and analysis,decision to publish,or preparation of the manuscript.

Appendix A.Supplementary material

Supplementary data associated with this article can be found in the online version at doi:10.1016/j.jpha.2018.04.003.