搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器降雨特性分析

張晶玲,周麗麗?,黃毅

(1.沈陽(yáng)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué),水利學(xué)院,110866,沈陽(yáng);2.沈陽(yáng)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué),土地與環(huán)境學(xué)院,110866,沈陽(yáng))

搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器降雨特性分析

張晶玲1,周麗麗1?,黃毅2

(1.沈陽(yáng)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué),水利學(xué)院,110866,沈陽(yáng);2.沈陽(yáng)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué),土地與環(huán)境學(xué)院,110866,沈陽(yáng))

降雨模擬器是進(jìn)行室內(nèi)或野外土壤侵蝕規(guī)律研究、降雨產(chǎn)流及入滲過(guò)程研究等的有效手段,目前野外降雨模擬器存在噴頭安裝高度大、有效降雨區(qū)域較小、與天然降雨有一定差別等問(wèn)題,本文針對(duì)以上問(wèn)題研制出一種可廣泛使用的搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器。通過(guò)率定降雨面積、降雨強(qiáng)度與均勻系數(shù)、雨滴中數(shù)直徑、終點(diǎn)速度與雨滴動(dòng)能六大降雨特性,探討該降雨裝置的適用性。結(jié)果表明:該裝置的降雨面積可達(dá)到100 m2,降雨均勻系數(shù)為41%;當(dāng)降雨面積為50 m2,供水壓力為0.32 kg/cm2時(shí),平均最大降雨強(qiáng)度為116.25 mm/h,最小降雨強(qiáng)度為61.01 mm/h,降雨均勻系數(shù)最大值為82%,最小值為46%,平均雨滴中數(shù)直徑D50為1.67 mm,平均雨滴終點(diǎn)速度為3.656 m/s,平均雨滴動(dòng)能為299.4 J/(m2·cm)。該裝置具有能耗小、重量輕、操作簡(jiǎn)單、便于移動(dòng)等優(yōu)點(diǎn),符合天然降雨規(guī)律,可滿(mǎn)足一般田間和野外試驗(yàn)的要求。

搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器;動(dòng)態(tài)上噴式;降雨面積;降雨均勻性;雨滴中數(shù)直徑

降雨模擬器是模擬天然降雨的一種試驗(yàn)設(shè)備,它可以縮短試驗(yàn)周期,加快雨水入滲規(guī)律和土壤侵蝕規(guī)律的研究過(guò)程[1]。對(duì)比自然降雨,降雨模擬器可以不受時(shí)間和空間的限制,還可以對(duì)降雨進(jìn)行有效控制,模擬不同降雨特性[2],具有經(jīng)濟(jì)、便捷、可重復(fù)等優(yōu)點(diǎn)[3]。國(guó)內(nèi)外研制的野外模擬降雨設(shè)備包括靜態(tài)下噴式、旋轉(zhuǎn)下噴式、側(cè)噴式、固定上噴式和動(dòng)態(tài)上噴式等。M.A.Clarke等[4]研制的一種針頭下滴式降雨裝置,屬于靜態(tài)下噴式模擬器,噴出的雨滴分布固定,與天然降雨相比真實(shí)性尚有距離?；粼泼返萚5]研制的QYJY503C人工模擬降雨裝置為旋轉(zhuǎn)下噴式,噴出的雨滴為動(dòng)態(tài),但是這種模擬器噴出的雨滴初速度不為零,不容易計(jì)算雨滴落地時(shí)的破壞力。陳文亮[6]研制的野外人工模擬降雨裝置為組合側(cè)噴式,水流經(jīng)過(guò)供水接管流到噴頭的孔板上,由孔板的錐形面和錐頂上的集流孔進(jìn)行集流形成水柱,水柱射向碎流擋板上,經(jīng)過(guò)碎流擋板被分散,形成近似扇形碎流面噴射出去,散落下來(lái)形成降雨,降雨雨滴直徑較大,受風(fēng)影響大。M.Esteves等[7]設(shè)計(jì)的EMIRE型組合上噴式人工模擬降雨裝置為固定上噴式,這種模擬器將水柱拋向高空,再散落下來(lái)形成雨滴,比較接近天然降雨,但該裝置為固定式不具有天然降雨的動(dòng)態(tài)性。動(dòng)態(tài)上噴式降雨模擬器通過(guò)搖臂將射向空中的水柱以不同的擺動(dòng)頻率散開(kāi),形成大小不等的雨滴,更接近天然降雨的特性。此外,現(xiàn)有野外降雨模擬器還存在噴頭普遍安裝在較高的支架上、耗時(shí)費(fèi)力、可移性較差[8]和有效降雨區(qū)域較小[9]等問(wèn)題。筆者針對(duì)以上問(wèn)題研制出一種可廣泛使用的搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器,此設(shè)備為動(dòng)態(tài)上噴式,通過(guò)搖擺后上噴水流,散落的雨滴初速度為零,上射水流在空中變化更能體現(xiàn)天然降雨的特性。該裝置降雨有效面積較大,體積小,安裝與操作方便,能夠滿(mǎn)足一般環(huán)境條件下野外降雨試驗(yàn)要求。

1 材料與方法

1.1 試驗(yàn)裝置與材料

1)搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器主要包括降雨支架、供水系統(tǒng)、萬(wàn)向直流式降雨噴頭、擺動(dòng)系統(tǒng)和動(dòng)力系統(tǒng)等5部分,立體結(jié)構(gòu)如圖1所示。當(dāng)電機(jī)11轉(zhuǎn)動(dòng)時(shí),通過(guò)曲柄連桿機(jī)構(gòu)10的傳動(dòng),“十字型”的搖臂7在一定擺幅內(nèi)往復(fù)運(yùn)動(dòng),通過(guò)安裝在支架上的萬(wàn)向直流噴頭將水柱噴向空中,水柱上升至20 m左右受空氣阻力影響而散開(kāi)形成雨滴,噴頭的往復(fù)運(yùn)動(dòng)決定了降雨區(qū)域的范圍。降雨過(guò)程中可以通過(guò)調(diào)節(jié)水壓、“十字型”搖臂的擺動(dòng)頻率、噴頭數(shù)量以及噴頭角度控制降雨強(qiáng)度和區(qū)域。試驗(yàn)采用搖臂上噴式降雨裝置的1,2,5號(hào)降雨噴頭。

圖1 降雨模擬器的立體示意圖Fig.1 Three dimensional schematic diagram of rainfall simulator

2)其他材料:涂料濾紙、雨滴取樣器、滑石粉、天平、燒杯、壓力表、曙紅、100 cm直鋼尺、毛刷、研缽、秒表、游標(biāo)卡尺、量杯、水桶、Φ=150 mm定性濾紙。

1.2 試驗(yàn)方法

1.2.1 降雨面積 降雨面積是指一場(chǎng)降雨中,雨滴降落到地面的覆蓋面積。由式(1)計(jì)算得出本裝置降雨控制面積。

式中:S為降雨控制面積,m2;L為徑流小區(qū)長(zhǎng),m;W為徑流小區(qū)寬,m。

1.2.2 降雨強(qiáng)度與均勻系數(shù)率定 降雨強(qiáng)度是指單位時(shí)段內(nèi)的降雨量。如圖2和表1所示,在10 m× 5 m的實(shí)驗(yàn)小區(qū)內(nèi),以(0,0)為原點(diǎn),X軸為橫坐標(biāo), Y軸為縱坐標(biāo),相鄰縱坐標(biāo)間距為1 m。縱坐標(biāo)為1、3、5的每排安置9個(gè)雨量筒,相鄰觀(guān)測(cè)點(diǎn)間距為1.25 m。0、2、4每排安置8個(gè)雨量筒作為觀(guān)測(cè)點(diǎn),除左右2個(gè)點(diǎn)與邊界距離為0.625 m,其余都為1.25 m。當(dāng)壓力控制為31 kPa、降雨時(shí)間為5 min、噴頭向前后左右4個(gè)方向偏移5種角度時(shí),通過(guò)測(cè)定每個(gè)點(diǎn)的降雨量,求出平均降雨量和降雨強(qiáng)度,然后由式(2)計(jì)算降雨均勻系數(shù)

式中:K為降雨均勻系數(shù),%;n為測(cè)點(diǎn)數(shù);Hi為各測(cè)點(diǎn)雨量為各測(cè)點(diǎn)平均雨量,mm。

表1 噴頭角度組合Tab.1 Nozzle angle combination

1.2.3 雨滴中數(shù)直徑、終點(diǎn)速度及雨滴動(dòng)能測(cè)定在10 m×5 m小區(qū)內(nèi),雨滴直徑測(cè)定布置如圖3所示。利用已經(jīng)制備的濾紙測(cè)得每個(gè)點(diǎn)的色斑直徑,并分別統(tǒng)計(jì)出直徑雨滴的個(gè)數(shù);根據(jù)公式d= 0.356D0.712,由色斑直徑D算出雨滴直徑d,再由雨滴直徑d求出雨滴質(zhì)量m,然后根據(jù)雨滴直徑的大小分為2種情況求出雨滴的速度,進(jìn)而計(jì)算降雨動(dòng)能,由總雨滴質(zhì)量和總雨滴動(dòng)能,換算為每m2面積

圖2 降雨強(qiáng)度率定布置圖Fig.2 Fixed layout of rainfall intensity rate

上1 cm降雨的動(dòng)能。

當(dāng)d＜1.9 mm時(shí),雨滴降落速度用修正的沙玉清公式[10]:

式中:

當(dāng)d≥1.9 mm時(shí),雨滴降落速度用修正的牛頓公式:

雨滴動(dòng)能公式:

式中:d為雨滴直徑,mm;V為雨滴終點(diǎn)速度,m/s;m為雨滴質(zhì)量,mg;E為雨滴動(dòng)能,J。

圖3 雨滴直徑測(cè)定布置圖Fig.3 Layout of measuring the diameters of raindrops

2 結(jié)果與分析

2.1 降雨面積

試驗(yàn)降雨面積見(jiàn)表2。本裝置最大降雨面積可達(dá)5×20 m2,平均降雨均勻系數(shù)為41%,左右兩側(cè)降雨很少,分布不均勻;因此選取降雨裝置正中間部分,降雨面積為5×10 m2作為試驗(yàn)區(qū)。當(dāng)采用1、2、5號(hào)噴頭、供水壓力為31 kPa、降雨控制面積為5× 10 m2時(shí),降雨均勻系數(shù)大于80%,能夠滿(mǎn)足試驗(yàn)要求。

表2 降雨面積表Tab.2 Effective rainfall area

2.2 降雨強(qiáng)度與均勻系數(shù)

本試驗(yàn)利用各測(cè)點(diǎn)的坐標(biāo)來(lái)描述降雨強(qiáng)度的最大值和最小值位置,降雨強(qiáng)度與均勻系數(shù)見(jiàn)表3。當(dāng)噴頭向前后移動(dòng)5°時(shí),在坐標(biāo)(8,5)獲得最大降雨強(qiáng)度為173.16 mm/h,坐標(biāo)(0,5)獲得最小降雨強(qiáng)度為41.84 mm/h,噴頭前后移動(dòng)均勻性系數(shù)分別為82%和80%。當(dāng)噴頭向左右移動(dòng)5°時(shí),在(13, 4)獲得最大降雨強(qiáng)度125.92 mm/h,在(15,0)獲得最小降雨強(qiáng)度0,可見(jiàn)該點(diǎn)沒(méi)有雨滴降落,為邊界無(wú)效點(diǎn)。噴頭左右移動(dòng)時(shí),均勻系數(shù)為78%和46%,低于80%。在均勻性方面,以降雨模擬器正方向?yàn)闇?zhǔn),相同壓力下,萬(wàn)向直流噴頭向前移動(dòng)的均勻系數(shù)比向后移動(dòng)的均勻系數(shù)大,均在80%以上,符合天然降雨的均勻性要求;但降雨噴頭向左右移動(dòng)均勻系數(shù)小,為左右兩側(cè)降雨量與中間觀(guān)測(cè)點(diǎn)分布不均造成。在降雨強(qiáng)度方面,噴頭向前后移動(dòng)的降雨強(qiáng)度大于向左右兩側(cè)移動(dòng)的降雨強(qiáng)度,是因?yàn)閲婎^擺動(dòng)對(duì)左右方向降雨量有影響,使左右降雨與中間區(qū)域分布不均勻。

2.3 雨滴中數(shù)直徑、終點(diǎn)速度與雨滴動(dòng)能

通過(guò)雨滴中數(shù)直徑圖獲得不同降雨強(qiáng)度下的雨滴中數(shù)直徑D50,見(jiàn)表4。雨滴中數(shù)直徑均在1.3mm以上,若參照其他學(xué)者的雨滴換算公式,與本研究計(jì)算結(jié)果比較,差值在0.1～0.3 mm之間,如果用0.2 mm來(lái)修正,其雨滴的中數(shù)直徑在1.5 mm以上。由表4可以看出,當(dāng)平均降雨強(qiáng)度為96.64 mm/h時(shí),雨滴中數(shù)直徑為1.67 mm,雨滴終點(diǎn)速度為3.66 mm/s,雨滴動(dòng)能為299.4 J/(m2·cm)。雨滴中數(shù)直徑隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增大而減小,但天然降雨的雨滴直徑卻隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增加而增大。這可能是由于3個(gè)降雨噴頭的孔徑是一定的,而雨滴中數(shù)直徑卻隨著上升高度的增大而降低的緣故,或者是因?yàn)榻涤陱?qiáng)度達(dá)到80～100 mm/h,D50不再增大反而減小。雨滴終點(diǎn)速度隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增加而降低,雨滴動(dòng)能隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增大而增大;但本裝置的1號(hào)、2號(hào)、5號(hào)3個(gè)噴頭雨滴的直徑隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增大而減小,可能是雨滴的密度非常大,導(dǎo)致雨滴的動(dòng)能仍然隨著降雨強(qiáng)度的增大而增大。

表3 降雨強(qiáng)度與均勻系數(shù)表Tab.3 Rainfall intensity and uniform coefficient

表4 雨滴中數(shù)直徑與終點(diǎn)速度Tab.4 Median diameter and terminal velocity of raindrops

3 結(jié)論

搖臂上噴式降雨模擬器體積小、重量輕,便于運(yùn)輸,尤其適宜進(jìn)行野外模擬降雨試驗(yàn);采用柴油機(jī)動(dòng)力,將提水、加壓、發(fā)電環(huán)節(jié)合而為一,能耗小,很好地解決了輸水和電力問(wèn)題;操作簡(jiǎn)單,便于控制。最大降雨面積可達(dá)5×20 m2,有效降雨面積為5×10 m2,其降雨均勻系數(shù)大于80%,滿(mǎn)足天然降雨的要求,可用于水土保持及其他相關(guān)領(lǐng)域的教學(xué)和科研。

[1] 陳文亮,唐克麗.SR型野外人工降雨模擬裝置[J].水土保持研究,2000,7(4):106. Chen Wenliang,Tang Keli.SR type field artificial rainfall simulator[J].Soil and Water Conservation Research,2000,7(4):106.(in Chinese)

[2] 倪際梁,何進(jìn),李洪文,等.便攜式人工模擬降雨裝置的設(shè)計(jì)與率定[J].農(nóng)業(yè)工程學(xué)報(bào),2012,28(24):78. Ni Jiliang,He Jin,Li Hongwen,et al.Design and rate of portable artificial simulated rainfall device[J].Journal of Agricultural Engineering,2012,28(24):78.(in Chinese)

[3] 周躍,王杰,胡少偉.Kust031型人工模擬降雨實(shí)驗(yàn)裝置的設(shè)計(jì)與率定[J].昆明理工大學(xué)學(xué)報(bào),2008,33 (2):81. Zhou Yue,Wang Jie,Hu Shaowei.Kust031 artificial simulated rainfall experiment device design and calibrate [J].Journal of Kunming University of Science and Technology,2008,33(2):81.(in Chinese)

[4] Clarke M A,Walsh R P D.A portable rainfall simulator for field assessment of splash and slopewash in remote locations[J].Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2007,32(13):2054.

[5] 霍云梅,畢華興,朱永杰,等.QYJY503C人工模擬降雨裝置降雨特性試驗(yàn)[J].中國(guó)水土保持科學(xué), 2015,13(2):32. Huo Yunmei,Bi Huaxing,Zhu Yongjie,et al.QYJY 503C artificial simulated rainfall simulator rainfall characteristics test[J].Science of Soil and Water Conservation,2015,13(2):32.(in Chinese)

[6] 陳文亮.組合側(cè)噴式野外人工模擬降雨裝置[J].水土保持通報(bào),1984,44. Chen Wenliang.Combined side spray type field artificial simulated rainfall device[J].Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation,1984,44.(in Chinese)

[7] Esteves M,Planchon O,Lapetite J M,et al.The‘EMIRE'large rainfall simulator:Design and field testing[J].Earth Surface Processes and Landforms,2000, 25:682.

[8] 劉素媛,韓奇志,聶振剛,等.SBYZCP人工降雨模擬裝置特性及應(yīng)用研究[J].土壤侵蝕與水土保持學(xué)報(bào), 1998,4(2):48. Liu Suyuan,Han Qizhi,Nie Zhengang,et al.Study on characteristics and application of SBYZCP artificial rainfall simulator[J].Journal of Soil Erosion and Soil and Water Conservation,1998,4(2):48.(in Chinese)

[9] Blanquies J,Scharff M,Hallock B.The design and construction of a rainfall simulator[J].International Erosion Control Association(IECA),2003:44

[10]吳發(fā)啟,張洪江.土壤侵蝕學(xué)[M].北京:科學(xué)出版社, 2012:33. Wu Faqi,Zhang Hongjiang.Soil erosion[M].Beijing: Science Press,2012:33.(in Chinese)

Rainfall characteristics of Rocker Arm Top Spray rainfall simulator

Zhang Jingling1,Zhou Lili1,Huang Yi2

(1.College of WaterResource,Shenyang Agricultural University,110866,Shenyang,China; 2.College of Soil and Environment,Shenyang Agricultural University,110866,Shenyang,China)

[Background]Rainfall simulator is commonly used in indoor and outdoor soil erosion research and the process of infiltration and rainfall runoff study.However,tall nozzles,small efficient rainfall area,and differences from natural rainfall constraint some rainfall simulators widely used.Based on all above,we developed a Rocker Arm Top Spray rainfall simulator which is supposed to be used widely.[Methods]The Rocker Arm Top Spray rainfall simulator we developed was composed of three rainfall nozzles(number1,2,and 5,aperture 9 mm),two middle rainfall nozzles(number 3 and 4, aperture 13 mm),Axle tube,“cross type”rocker arm,Axle hole,connecting rod,crank connecting rod mechanism,motor,hose,main water supply pipe,pressure gauge and water well pipeline interface.The precipitation area,rainfall intensity,average rainfall uniformity coefficient,median diameter of raindrops,terminal velocity and the kinetic energy of rain were measured,and the applicability of the rainfall simulator was discussed.[Results]Rainfall uniformity value was 41%,when the rainfall area was 100 m2,which maybe the maximum rainfall area of the simulator.When the rainfall area was 50 m2, water pressure was 0.32 kg/cm2,the rainfall uniformity value was 82%for the maximum rainfall intensity(116.25 mm/h)and 46%for the minimum rainfall intensity(61.01 mm/h).Under the same pressure, the rainfall uniformity value range changed from 46%to 82%.The rainfall uniformity value was 82% when the rainfall nozzles moving forward,while the rainfall uniformity value was 80%when the rainfall nozzles moving backward.That means that when the rainfall nozzles moving forward and backward,the rainfall uniformity value was more than 80%,which accorded with the requirements of natural rainfall uniformity.But the average rainfall uniformity value was smaller than 80%when the rainfall nozzle moving left and right,which might be caused by the uneven rainfall.The rain intensity was related to the rainfall median diameter.The measured average median diameter(D50),the average terminal velocity of raindrops,and the average raindrop kinetic energy was 1.67 mm,3.656 m/s and 299.4 J/(m2·cm) respectively,under the different rainfall intensity.The median diameter value presented decreasing trend with the increase of rainfall intensity,but the median diameter of natural rainfall increased with the increase of rainfall intensity,which may be caused by the definite apertures of the three rainfall nozzle. The median diameter decreased with the height increasing,or because the rainfall intensity reached 80～100 mm/h the measured median diameter no longer increased.With the increase of rainfall intensity,the terminal velocity of raindrops tended to decrease,but the kinetic energy of raindrops showed an increasing trend.That was probably because that the droplet density was very large,the kinetic energy of rainfall increased with the rainfall intensity increasing.[Conclusions]The device was small,light,in simple operation and convenient movement,especially suitable for field rainfall simulation,which can meet the requirements of the general field and outdoor experiments.

Rocker Arm Top Spray rainfall simulator;dynamic spray type;rainfall area;rainfall uniformity coefficient;median diameter

P481;TH765

A

1672-3007(2016)06-0125-06

10.16843/j.sswc.2016.06.016

2016 04 05

2016 06 20

項(xiàng)目名稱(chēng):國(guó)家自然科學(xué)基金項(xiàng)目“東北黑土區(qū)壟作農(nóng)田融雪侵蝕過(guò)程中氮磷遷移轉(zhuǎn)化機(jī)制研究”(41471225);遼寧省農(nóng)業(yè)領(lǐng)域青年科技創(chuàng)新人才培養(yǎng)計(jì)劃“遼寧省土壤侵蝕預(yù)報(bào)”(2014054);遼寧省高等學(xué)校優(yōu)秀人才支持計(jì)劃“凍融條件下秸稈覆蓋坡面磷素流失研究”(LJQ2013074)

張晶玲(1992—),女,研究生。主要研究方向:土壤侵蝕與徑流泥沙研究。E-mail:2512863471@qq.com

?通信作者簡(jiǎn)介:周麗麗(1979—),女,博士,副教授。主要研究方向:土壤侵蝕與流域治理。E-mail:zhoulilia@163.com