Baseline Sensitivity of Botrytis cinerea from Liaoning Province to Boscalid

Yan LIU,Zhiqiu QI,Baoyan HAN,Bochui ZHAO,Mingshan JI

College of Plant Protection,Shenyang Agricultural University,Shenyang 110866,China

Botrytis,caused byBotrytis cinerea,is a worldwide fungal disease[1-2].In recent years,with the continuous expansion of protected areas,botrytis is becoming severer and severer,and it has become the main disease in facility cultivation of tomato in China,especially in north ern areas[3-4].Currently,benzimidazole fungicide carbendazim,anilino pyrimidine fungicide pyrimethanil and dicarboximide fungicide procymidone are commonly used to prevent and control botrytis in tomato.However,due to long-term use,drug resistance has been generated inB.cinerea.Thus the prevention effect againstB.cinereais greatly reduced,leading to heavy losses to tomato production[5-10].The resistance ofB.cinereato common fungicides has aroused worldwide attention[11-14].

Boscalid is a new nicotinamide fungicidedevelopedbytheBASF Corporation in 1992[15].It is a systemic fungicide,and has broad spectrum,especially against gray mold,powdery mildew,rot,sclerotinia and various rot diseases in economic crops.Boscalid is an inhibitor against coenzyme Q reductase in mitochondrial respiratory chain, affecting celldivision and growth,eventually leading to cell death[16].Ritaet al.[17]found botrytis-resistantB.cinereastrain in tomato.Yuet al.[19]also found botrytis-resistantB.cinereastrain in tomato in Shanxi Province.However,there have been no reports about resistance ofB.cinereato boscalid in tomato in Liaoning Province.In order to avoid and delay the generation of resistance ofB.cinereato boscalid,risk assessment on resistance ofB.cinereato boscalid is urged to be conducted.

Materials and Methods

Materials

Test strainThe samples were collected from ten different urban areas of Liaoning Province,and total165 strains ofB.cinereawere separated.The strains were preserved on PDA plate.They were named in accordance with the principle of"First capital letter of collection site+number".

Test reagentsThe boscalid stock solution(87.4% )was provided by the Institute of Vegetables and Flowers,Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences.The mother liquor of boscalid(10 000 μg/ml)was prepared by diluting the stock solution with acetone.

Test mediumThe prepared PDA medium was cooled to about 45℃and then mixed with different concentrations of boscalid solutions(v∶v,1∶9).Thus the boscalid-containing PDA medium was prepared.

Methods

Determination method of sensitivity of B.cinerea to boscalidThe sensitivity ofB.cinereato boscalid was determined by the mycelial growth rate method[18].Under sterile conditions,the colonies ofB.cinereaon the boscalidcontaining PDA plate were sampled using a punch with a diameter of 5 mm.The sampledB.cinereacolonies were inoculated downward on new PDA plates containing different concentrations (0,0.0625,0.25,1.0,4.0 and 16.0 μg/ml)of boscalid,and cultured at 25℃for 3 d.There were three replicates for each treatment.The diameters of colonies were measured using the crossing method.The mycelial growth inhibition rates ofB.cinereain PDA medium containing different concentrations of boscalid were calculated according to the following formula:

Mycelial growth inhibition rate=(Average colony diameter in the control group-Average colony diameter in the treatmentgroups)/(Average colony diameter in the control group-0.5)×100%.

The data statistics were conducted using the DPS data processing system.The mycelial growth inhibition rates ofB.cinereawere converted into probability values,and the concentrations of boscalid were converted into their logarithms.With the logarithm of boscalid concentration as the horizontal axis,and the probability value as the vertical axis,the regression equation (y=a+bx)was fitted.According to the regression equation of virulence,theEC50values of boscalid against variousB.cinereastrains and the correlation coefficients(r)were calculated.

Establishment of sensitivity baseline of B.cinerea to boscalidAccording to the sensitivity range ofB.cinereato boscalid,theEC50values were divided evenly into several stages.With the final value ofEC50at each stage as the horizontal axis,and the frequency of sensitivity as the vertical axis,the frequency distribution of sensitivities ofB.cinereastrains to boscalid were drawn.If theEC50values were in line with normal distribution,the mean ofEC50values can be treated as the sensitivity baseline ofB.cinereafrom Liaoning Province to boscalid.

Results and Analysis

Establishment of sensitivity baseline of B.cinerea to boscalid

K-S test was conducted for the obtained data by using SPSS software.After removing the 7 strains that did not meet the conditions,theZvalue was 1.335,and thePvalue was 0.057.Since thePvalue was above 0.05,the sensitivity frequency of the 158 testB.cinereastrains to boscalid was in line with normal distribution.Within the sensitivity range ofB.cinereato boscalid,theEC50values were divided into five stages with intercept of 1.000 μg/ml.With theEC50final values as the horizontal axis,and the sensitivity frequency as the vertical axis,the frequency distribution of sensitivity ofB.cinereato boscalid was drawn(Fig.1).

As shown in Fig.1,theEC50values of boscalid against variousB.cinereastrains were mainly concentrated in the range of 1.000-2.000 μg/ml(41.14% ),but the sensitivity frequencies in the other intervals were reduced successively.The averageEC50value of boscalid against the 158B.cinereastrains was 1.9731±1.001 1 μg/ml,and the averageEC50value(1.973 1 μg/ml)was initially treated as the sensitivity baseline ofB.cinereafrom Liaoning Province to boscalid.

Table 1 Sensitivity of B.cinerea to boscalid

Sensitivity comparison of B.cinerea strain to boscalid among different regions

The frequency distribution of sensitivities ofB.cinereastrains to boscalid was determined by the mycelial growth rate method(Fig.2).The sensitivity frequencies were distributed continuously.The differences in sensitivity ofB.cinereato boscalid were also tested among different regions.As shown in Table 1,theEC50values of boscalid against variousB.cinereastrains ranged from 0.080 0 to 7.787 2 μg/ml,and the maximum EC50 value was 97.34 times higher than the minimum.The averageEC50value was highest in Dalian,but was lowest in Dandong.TheEC50values in Dalian were significantly higher than those in the other regions,indicating that theB.cinereastrains in Dalian were less sensitive to boscalid.This might be caused by earlier and more application ofboscalid in Dalian,which still needs further testing and verification.

Cluster analysis of sensitivities of B.cinerea strains from different origins to boscalid

Total 50B.cinereastrains were collected randomly from 10 different regions(5 strains from each region)of Liaoning Province.The cluster analysis(Fig.3)showed that theEC50values of the 50 strains were mainly divided into 7 groups.Total 14 strains were clustered into the first group,including BX-17,FS-09,BX-19,AS-09,FX-11,FS-03,FS-06,CY-14,AS-03,PJ-14,FX-01,SY-08,PJ-08 and FS-10;total 5 strains were clustered into the second group,including DL-12,CY-07,AS-11,HLD-12 and FS-04;total 11 strains clustered into the third group,including DD-01,DD-14,HLD-19,DD-20,SY-07,DD-03,SY-04,FX-05,HLD-15,BX-03 and BX-14;total 13 strains were clustered into the fourth group,including CY-11,AS-01,BX-07,CY-02,CY-20,SY-02,AS-04,SY-01,DD-08,HLD-04,HLD-07,PJ-16 and FX-02;total 4 strains were clustered into the fifth group,including FX-15,PJ-02,DL-01 and PJ-04;there were only two strains clustered into the sixth group,including DL-06 and DL-08;there were only one strain (DL-17)clustered into the seventh group.The strains from different regions were clustered into one group,indicating that the differences in sensitivity ofB.cinereato boscalid have no significant correlation with geographic origin ofB.cinerea.The DL-06 and DL-08 were gathered into one group,and theirEC50values were highest(6.640 9 and 6.872 3 μg/ml).It suggests that these twoB.cinereastrains are least sensitive to boscalid,and drug resistance is easiest to be generated in them.

Conclusions and Discussion

Yuet al.[19]found that theEC50values ofboscalid againstB.cinereastrains from Shanxi Province ranged from 0.22 to 11.67 μg/ml,and the maximumEC50value was 53.05 times higherthantheminimum.Inthis study,theEC50values of boscalid againstB.cinereastrains from Liaoning Province ranged from 0.080 0 to 7.787 2 μg/ml,and the maximumEC50value was 97.34 times higher than the minimum;the averageEC50value of boscalid against the 165 testB.cinereastrains was 2.194 9±1.334 1 μg/ml.Therefore,there is small difference in sensitivity ofB.cinereato boscalid between Shanxi and Liaoning Provinces.In Liaoning Province,although the difference in maximum and minimumEC50values is greater,theB.cinereastrains are still in a sensitive stage to boscalid,indicating that theB.cinereastrains in greenhouse are still sensitive to boscalid.There are great differences inEC50value of boscalid among differentB.cinereastrains,which may be related to physiological differences amongB.cinereastrains in the nature.

There is great genetic variability inB.cinerea,so it is easy to produce drug resistance in production.The establishment of sensitivity baseline ofB.cinereato boscalid is the basis for identifying and detecting resistance inB.cinereaagainst boscalid,and it is of great significance for avoiding and delaying the generation of drug resistance inB.cinerea.Boscalid is an inhibitor against coenzyme Q reductase in mitochondrial respiratory chain,and it has a single site of action,so drug resistance is easy to be generated in pathogenic strains.Therefore,in the application,boscalid,along with other agents with differentmechanisms,should be used alternatively to avoid and delay the generation of drug resistance inB.cinerea,thereby improving the therapeutic effect of boscalid againstB.cinerea.

[1]JIA XH(賈曉華).Sensitivity baseline of Botrytis cinerea and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum to pyrimethanil and resistance ofBotrytis cinerea(番茄灰霉病菌和油菜菌核病菌對(duì)嘧霉胺的敏感性基線及番茄灰霉病菌抗藥性研究)[D].Nanjing:Nanjing Agricultural University(南京:南京農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué)),2004.

[2]LAMONDIA JA,DOUGLAS SM.Sensitivity ofBotrytis cinereafrom Connecticut greenhouses to benzimidazole and dicarboximide fungicides[J].Plant Disease,1997,81:729-732.

[3]ZHONG CY(張從宇),GAO ZM(高智謀),YUE YD(岳永德).Stuy on biological characteristics ofBotrytis cinerea(番茄灰霉病菌生物學(xué)性狀研究)[J].Journal of Anhui Technical Teachers College(安徽技術(shù)師范學(xué)院學(xué)報(bào)),2002,16(3):10-14.

[4]GU RG(古仁剛),HE T(何濤),ZHU XL(朱小麗),et al.Occurrence and comprehensive control ofBotrytis cinereain greenhouse(溫棚番茄灰霉病的發(fā)生與綜合防治)[J].Northwest Horticulture(西北園藝),2015,1:41-42.

[5]HAN J(韓君),FAN HF(范懷峰),WANG HN (王海娜),et al.Development progress of fungicides againstBotrytis cinerea(防治灰霉病藥劑的開(kāi)發(fā)進(jìn)展)[J].Agrochemicals Research&Application(農(nóng)藥研究與應(yīng)用),2011,15(2):3-9.

[6]ZHAO Y(趙楊),MIAO ZY(苗則彥),LI Y(李穎),et al.Research progress on controlling against tomato gray mold(番茄灰霉病防治研究進(jìn)展)[J].China Plant Protection(中國(guó)植保導(dǎo)刊),2014,7:21-29.

[7]SONG X(宋晰),XIAO L(肖露),LIN D(林東),et al.Detection of procymidone resistance and investigation of biological characteristics inBotrytis cinerea(番茄灰霉病菌對(duì)腐霉利的抗藥性檢測(cè)及生物學(xué)性狀研究)[J].Chinese Journal of Pesticide Science(農(nóng)藥學(xué)學(xué)報(bào)),2013,15(4):398-404.

[8]JI MS(紀(jì)明山),CHEN GW(程根武),ZHANG YX(張益先),et al.Studies on resistance to carbendazim and diethofencarb ofBotrytis cinerea(灰霉病菌對(duì)多菌靈和乙霉威抗性研究)[J].Journal of Shenyang Agricultural University(沈陽(yáng)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué)學(xué)報(bào)),1997,29(3):213-216.

[9]CHEN ZF(陳治芳),WANG WQ(王文橋),HAN XY(韓秀英),et al.Review of chemical control of gray mould and fungicide resistance ofBotrytis cinerea(灰霉病化學(xué)防治及抗藥性研究進(jìn)展)[J].Journal of Hebei Agricultural Sciences(河北農(nóng)業(yè)科學(xué)),2010,14(9):19-23.

[10]JI MS(紀(jì)明山),QI ZQ(祁之秋),WANG YZ(王英姿),et al.Resistance ofBotrytis cinereato pyrimethanil in tomato(番茄灰霉病菌對(duì)嘧霉胺的抗藥性)[J].Acta Phytophylacica Sinica(植物保護(hù)學(xué)報(bào)),2003,30(4):396-400.

[11]MALANDRAKIA A,MARKOGLOU A,ZIOGAS B.Molecular characterization of benzimidazole-resistantB.cinereafield isolates with reduced or enhanced sensitivity to zoxamide and diethofencarb[J].Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology,2011,99:118-124.

[12]RODRIGUEZ A,ACOSTA A,RODRIGUEZC.Fungicide resistance ofBotrytis cinereain tomato greenhouses in the Canary Islands and effectiveness of non-chemical treatments against gray mold[J].World J Microbiol Biotechnol,2014,30:2397-2406.

[13]HANS-JUERGEN,ROSSLENBROICH,DIETRICH STUEBLER.Botrytis cinerea-history of chemical control and novel fungicides for its management[J].Crop Protection,2000,19:557-561.

[14]PAPPAS AC.Evolution of fungicide resistance inBotrytis cinereain protected crops in Greece[J].Crop Protection,1997,16:257-263.

[15]XIONG XS(熊曉妹).Boscalid,a new fungicide(殺菌劑新品種—啶酰菌胺制劑的研究)[J].Agrochemicals Research&Application(農(nóng)藥研究與應(yīng)用),2006,10(4):21-23.

[16]YAN FY(顏范勇),LIU DQ(劉冬青),SIMA LF(司馬利鋒),et al.Boscalid,a novel carboxamide aka anilide class of fungicides(新型煙酰胺類(lèi)殺菌劑—啶酰菌胺)[J].Agrochemicals(農(nóng)藥),2008,47(2):132-135.

[17]RITA M.Selection,characterization and genetic analysis of laboratory mutants ofBotryotinia fuckeliana(Botrytis cinerea)resistantto the fungicide boscalid[J].PlantPathology,2010,128:185-199.

[18]MU LY(慕立義).Research Methods for Plant Chemical Protection(植物化學(xué)保護(hù)研究方法)[M].Beijing:China Agriculture Press(北京:中國(guó)農(nóng)業(yè)出版社),1994.

[19]YU L(余玲),LIU HP(劉慧平),HAN JC(韓巨才),et al.Sensitivity ofBotrytis cinereafrom ShanxiProvince to boscalid(山西省灰霉菌對(duì)啶酰菌胺的敏感性測(cè)定)[J].Journal of Shanxi Agricultural University(山西農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué)學(xué)報(bào)),2012,32(3):232-234.