Computed tomography angiographic study of surgical anatomy of thyroid arteries: Clinical implications in neck dissection

Yashu Bhardwaj, Brijendra Singh, Pooja Bhadoria, Rashmi Malhotra, Swarnava Tarafdar, Kanchan Bisht

Abstract

BACKGROUND

The course and variations of thyroid arteries must be understood by surgeons to prevent bleeding during operative procedures of the thyroid gland. There is limited scientific literature regarding the radiological anatomy of thyroid arteries in this geographical area, the Garhwal region of Sub-Himalayan belt, which is considered to be the endemic belt of goiter. Computed tomography angiography provides a three-dimensional orientation of the vascular and surgical anatomy of the entire cervical region.

AIM

To estimate the proportion of variation in origin of thyroid arteries using Computed Tomography Angiography.

METHODS

Using Computed Tomography Angiography, the presence and origin of the superior thyroid artery, inferior thyroid artery, and thyroid ima artery were observed and assessed.

RESULTS

Out of total 210 subjects, superior thyroid artery was seen to be emerging from external carotid artery in 77.1% cases. The artery was found to be originating at the level of bifurcation of common carotid artery in 14.3% cases, whereas in 8.6% cases, it emerged as a direct branch of the common carotid artery. Similarly, the inferior thyroid artery was observed to be emerging from thyrocervical trunk, subclavian artery and vertebral artery in 95.7% cases, 3.3% and 1% cases, respectively. Thyroid ima artery was also reported in a subject, arising from the brachiocephalic trunk.

CONCLUSION

To avoid vascular injuries, excessive and uncontrollable bleeding, intra-operative difficulties, and post-operative issues, it is imperative for surgeons to be aware of the course and variations of thyroid arteries

Key Words: Thyroid arteries; Computed tomography angiography; Origin; Variation

INTRODUCTION

The thyroid gland is an endocrine gland, which is essential for the normal metabolism and growth of an individual. Conditions affecting the thyroid gland range from simple goiter to malignant thyroid nodule and thyroid carcinoma. Thyroidectomy or hemithyroidectomy is occasionally indicated to remove a malignant thyroid tumor. The neck is also explored for surgical procedures, such as lobectomy, selective embolization of the thyroid, emergency cricothyroidotomy, radical neck dissection, diagnostic and therapeutic catheterization, reconstruction of the aneurysm, and carotid endarterectomy[1]. Bleeding during the operative procedure of the thyroid gland may compress the trachea causing difficulty in breathing[2].

Thyroid is a richly vascularized gland, which is supplied by superior thyroid artery (STA), inferior thyroid artery (ITA) and thyroid ima artery (TIA). The superior thyroid artery usually arises from external carotid artery and runs in close proximity to external branch of superior laryngeal nerve, before entering the fascia of thyroid and giving anterior and posterior branch.

Inferior thyroid artery usually commences from thyrocervical trunk[3]. Occasionally there is presence of a single minor artery, thyroid ima artery in 10% of the individuals[4].

The course and variations of the thyroid arteries must be understood by surgeons to prevent bleeding during the operative procedure of the thyroid gland.

There is limited scientific literature regarding the radiological anatomy of thyroid arteries in this geographical area, the Garhwal region of Sub-Himalayan belt, which is considered to be the endemic belt of goiter[5]. Computed tomography (CT) angiography provides a three-dimensional orientation of the vascular and surgical anatomy of the entire cervical region. For vascular mapping, radiography is a non-invasive multiplanar imaging method[6]. The present study investigated the origin and variation of thyroid arteries with the help of CT angiography.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The proposed study was done in the Department of Anatomy in collaboration with the Department of Radiodiagnosis over a period of 18 months. A total of 210 samples were included as per inclusion and exclusion criteria. Patients above 18 years who underwent CT angiography were included. Patients who had undergone previous common carotid occlusions or known vascular abnormalities (carotid hypoplasia, plaque in the carotid bifurcation, aneurysms) were excluded. Following the approval of Institutional Ethics Committee, with ethical clearance number AIIMS/IEC/21/323, CT angiographic data from 64-slice CT scanner and 128-slice CT scanner were collected from the Department of Radiodiagnosis. Reconstruction of the three-dimensional views of the images were done using RadiAnt DICOM Viewer (RadiAnt ?), a software installed in the MSI laptop PC. The images, thus obtained, were observed and evaluated for variations. The images were analyzed as per the general anatomical course and branches of vessels and variations, if present, were noted. The statistical analysis was done using the chi square test and the Stuart-Maxwell test.

Study sample size

The sample size for the proposed study was 208, considering our primary objective, which was to study variation in origin of superior thyroid artery. Previous studies have shown that the percentage of variation in the superior thyroid artery ranged from 6.5%-18.5%. We selected 6.5% to calculate our sample size with 10% (65) of relative procedure and finite population correction factor as 216 with 95% of confidence level and alpha error as 5%. The calculated sample size was 208. We used Open Epi, Version 3, open source calculator for the calculation of same.

RESULTS

We collected 210 samples; however, the calculated sample size for the present study was 208. Out of total 210 participants, 162 (77.1%) participants had the superior thyroid artery originating from the external carotid artery. Participants with superior thyroid artery originating from level of bifurcation of common carotid artery were 30 (14.3%), whereas participants who had origin of superior thyroid artery from common carotid artery were 18 (8.6%). Figure 1 represents the CT angiographic image of various origin of superior thyroid artery in the axial plane.

Figure 1 Computed tomography angiographic image (axial section). A: Showing the origin of the right superior thyroid artery from the external carotid artery; B: Bifurcation of the common carotid artery; C: Common carotid artery. STA: Superior thyroid artery; ECA: External carotid artery; ICA: Internal carotid artery; VA: Vertebral artery; CCB: Bifurcation of common carotid artery.

Participants who had origin of inferior thyroid artery from thyrocervical trunk, subclavian artery, and vertebral artery were 201 (95.7%), 7 (3.3%), and 2 (1.0%), respectively. Figure 2 represent the origin of inferior thyroid artery from left & right subclavian arteries and thyrocervical trunk respectively.

Figure 2 Computed tomography. A: Origin of inferior thyroid artery from left subclavian artery; B: Right subclavian artery; C: Right thyrocervical trunk. ITA: Inferior thyroid artery; VA: Vertebral artery; CCA: Common carotid artery.

Out of total 210 cases, we observed one case that had origin of thyroid ima artery from brachiocephalic trunk (Figure 3).

Figure 3 Showing origin of thyroid ima artery from the brachiocephalic trunk. TIA: Thyroid ima artery; BT: Brachiocephalic trunk.

The overall difference in the origin of superior thyroid artery was statistically significant (Stuart-Maxwell test:χ2= 11.632,P= 0.003) (Table 1).

Table 1 Comparison between the origin of superior thyroid arteries on right and left side (n = 105), n (%)

The overall difference in the origin of inferior thyroid artery was not statistically significant (Stuart-Maxwell test:χ2= 5.000,P= 0.082) (Table 2).

Table 2 Comparison between the origin of inferior thyroid arteries on right and left side (n = 105), n (%)

The following variables were significantly associated (P＜ 0.05) with the variable 'Gender':

The association between “gender” and the “origin of STA” was investigated using theχ2test (Table 3).

Table 3 Association between gender and the origin of superior thyroid artery (n = 210), n (%)

Regarding the distribution of the origin of the STA, there was no discernible difference between the various groups (χ2= 1.409,P= 0.494).

Cramer’s V value for the strength of association between the two variables is 0.08, which is considered to have little or no association in this study.

The distribution of the origin of ITA did not significantly differ across the different groups (χ2= 2.059,P= 0.545) (Table 4).

Table 4 Association between gender and the origin of inferior thyroid artery (n = 210), n (%)

The connection of the two variables for Cramer’s V strength was 0.1, which is considered to be little or no association in this study.

DISCUSSION

The STA is considered to be a branch of external carotid artery (ECA) in normal anatomy. The STA can also originate from common carotid artery or bifurcation of common carotid artery, according to studies that have investigated the variability in the origin site of the superior thyroid artery from the carotid arteries. The inferior thyroid artery is generally considered a branch of the thyrocervical trunk, while it can also originate from subclavian artery, vertebral artery and common carotid artery according to previous research[7]. Although thyroid ima artery is considered to originate from brachiocephalic trunk, in some cases it originates directly from arch of aorta[8].

In the present study, we have observed that the STA originated from ECA, common carotid artery (CCA) and bifurcation of common carotid artery (CCB) in 77%, 14.3% and 8.6% of the cases, respectively. However, in the case of ITA the variation in origin was seen only in 3.3% of cases from subclavian artery (SA) and in 1% case from vertebral artery (VA) with varying level of origin of thyrocervical trunk (TCT).

Sreedharanet al[7] in 2018 did a cadaveric study depending on the frequency of origin of STA coming from ECA, CCB, or CCA. With an incidence of 88.33%, the STA originated from ECA in 53 of the 60 hemi-neck specimens. A total of 5 out of 60 hemi-necks showed that STA appeared at the CCB in 8.33% of cases. The STA developed from the CCA in 2 of the 60 patients, with an incidence of 3.33%. In the present study the overall difference in the origin of STA was statistically significant (Stuart-Maxwell test:χ2= 11.632,P= 0.003) on right and left sides, which is shown in Table 1.

Anagnostopoulouet al[9] in 2014 conducted a study on 68 formalin-embalmed adult cadavers regarding superior thyroid artery only and categorized their result in three major groups. Type A consisted of cases in which the STA originates from ECA, Type B includes cases in which STA originates from CCA and Type C constitutes cases in which STA originates from the level of CCB. In 36.8% (25/68) of the patients, Type A was found on the right side, and in 42.6% (29/68) of the cases, on the left. In 32.4% (22/68) and 38.2% (26/68) of the individuals, type B was seen on the right and left side, respectively. In 19.1% (13/68) and 30.9% (21/68) of cases, Type C variation was noted on the right and left sides. In our study, superior thyroid artery originated from ECA in majority of cases followed by level of CCB and then CCA, on left side with 72 (68.6%), 23 (21.9%) and 10 (9.5%) cases, respectively and on the right side the order of frequency of origin of superior thyroid artery is from ECA, CCA and then CCB contrary to study done by Anagnostopoulouet al[9].

Shankaret al[10] in 2017 did a cadaveric study on 80 superior thyroid arteries with 40 right and 40 Left arteries, and found that it originated from the external carotid artery in 43 (53.75%), from CCB in 12 (15%), and the CCA in 25 (31.265%) cases[6]. The results of this study are similar to that of the present study as in the present study STA arose from ECA in 90 (85.7%) and 72 (68.6%) cases, on the right and left sides respectively, as the most common site of origin on both sides.

Esenet al[11] in 2017 did an angiographic study on 640 patients in which on the right (64.5%) and left (39.7%) sides, the STA was frequently originated from the ECA. In their study, there were 608 (95%) and 578 (90.3%) right and left ITAs emerging from the thyrocervical trunk, respectively. A single root from the SA gave rise to 18 (2.8%) right and 13 (2.0%) left ITAs. The VA was the origin of four left ITAs. In 15 patients (2.3%), the TIA was identified. A total of 12 of these were brachiocephalic arteries, 2 were right CCAs, and 1 was an aortic arch[7]. In present study the right and left STA arises from ECA in 90 (85.7%) and 72 (68.6%) cases respectively, whereas in the remaining 30 (14.3%) and 18 (8.6%) cases the STA originates from the level of CCB and main trunk of CCA respectively. However, ITA arise from TCT in 103 (98.1%) cases on right and 98 (93.3%) cases on left and among remaining cases 7 (3.3%) arise from SA and 2 (1.0%) arise from VA. We found TIA in 1 case originating from BT.

Tsegayet al[12] performed a cadaveric study in 2019 and observed that, the ECA was identified as the most frequent location of STA origin. The TCT gave rise to the ITA in each case, while in the present study the result for STA corresponds with the given study as in majority of cases the STA arises from ECA on both the sides, whereas in the case of ITA present study does not correspond with given study as in present study the ITA takes origin from thyrocervical trunk, SA, and VA in 201 (95.7%), 7 (3.3%) and 2 (1.0%) cases, respectively.

Guptaet al[13] performed an angiographic study in 2020, on 15 Indian patients indigenously from New Delhi region who were examined with a total of 25 selective STA angiograms. ECA was the primary source of STA on both sides. Ten patients (71.5%) had right STAs with ECA origins, while eight (72.5%) had left STAs with ECA origins. The bifurcation of the CCA accounted for 3 (21%) right STA and 2 (18.5%) left STA, making it the second most frequent site of STA genesis. CCA (right STA) and internal carotid artery (left STA) were the least frequent sites of origin, each accounting for one instance. In the present study, we considered a sample size of 210 patients from population of Uttarakhand, India. Guptael al[13] in their study used DSA technique and also noted the branching patterns of STA only but in our study we observed the CT angiographic data and evaluated STA, ITA as well as TIA.

Dhindsaet al[14] in 2014 found during a routine cadaveric dissection on male cadaver that STA on left side was arising from CCA, while on right it was originating from ECA only[10]. In the present study, we evaluated the data of 112 male patients and found that in 89 (79.5%) cases the STA arose from ECA, in 13 (11.6%) cases STA originated from level of CCB and in 10 (8.9%) cases the STA originated from CCA main trunk.

Vázquezet al[15] performed a cadaveric study and indicated that there are four different types of origin of STA. In type 1 STA originated from the level of CCB in 102 (49%) of cases. Type 2 was when STA originated from CCA in 55 (27%) of cases. There is a statistically significant difference between the frequency of type 2 origins on the left and right. On the other hand, there was no statistically significant distinction between male and female Type 2 origins. In Type 3, the STA arose from ECA in 48 (23%) cases. In our study we did not categorize the types, but we found that STA arose 120 from CCA, level of CCB and ECA in 18 (8.6%), 30 (14.3%), and 162 (77.1%) cases, respectively and in our study the overall difference in the origin of STA was statistically significant (Stuart-Maxwell test:χ2= 11.632,P= 0.003) on right and left sides which is shown in Table 1.

In the present study the measurement of the thyroid arteries was not done.

CONCLUSION

In our study, 77% of the cases had ECA as the source of STA and in more than 22% of cases variation were seen in the origin of STA, from CCA and CCB. Variation in the level of bifurcation of CCA was also seen, which greatly changes the course of STA. The present study reveals the variation in origin of ITA is 4%, while its course varied with varying level of origin of TCT. We found that thyroid ima artery is not frequently present, but was present in only one case and can lead to severe hemorrhagic condition if remains unnoticed.

ARTICLE HIGHLIGHTS

Research background

An individual's normal growth and metabolism depend on the thyroid gland, an endocrine organ.Simple goiter, thyroid cancer, and malignant thyroid nodules are just a few of the conditions that can affect the thyroid gland. Sometimes it is necessary to perform a thyroidectomy or hemithyroidectomy in order to remove a malignant thyroid tumor. Additionally, the neck is examined for surgical treatments such as lobectomy, carotid endarterectomy, emergency cricothyroidotomy, radical neck dissection,diagnostic and therapeutic catheterization, and selective thyroid embolization. Breathing difficulties may result from tracheal compression brought on by bleeding during the thyroid gland surgery.

Research motivation

To avoid complications during thyroid surgeries, surgeons must be aware of the path and variations of the thyroid arteries. The Garhwal region of the Sub-Himalayan belt, which is thought to be the endemic zone of goitre, has little scientific literature on the radiological anatomy of thyroid arteries. A threedimensional orientation of the vascular and surgical anatomy of the entire cervical region is provided by computed tomography angiography.

Research objectives

Radiography is a non-invasive multiplanar imaging technique for vascular mapping. The objective of the current research was to examine the origin and variation of thyroid arteries, with the aid of Computed Tomography angiography, Surgeons must be familiar with the course and variations of the thyroid arteries to prevent difficulties during thyroid operations.

Research methods

Patients with known vascular anomalies (carotid hypoplasia, plaque in the carotid bifurcation,aneurysms) or past common carotid occlusions were excluded. Following the Institutional Ethics Committee's consent, the Department of Radiodiagnosis obtained computed tomography (CT)angiographic data from 64-slice and 128-slice CT scanners. RadiAnt DICOM Viewer (RadiAnt), a programme installed on the MSI laptop PC, was used to reconstruct the three-dimensional views of the photos. The Stuart-Maxwell test and the chi square test were employed in the statistical study.

Research results

Out of 210 individuals, 77.1% of the time the superior thyroid artery was observed to be arising from the external carotid artery. In 14.3% of cases, the artery was shown to originate at the point where the common carotid artery splits, whereas in 8.6% of cases, it was discovered to be a direct branch of the common carotid artery. Similar to this, in 95.7%, 3.3%, and 1% of cases, respectively, the inferior thyroid artery was seen to be arising from the thyrocervical trunk, subclavian artery, and vertebral artery.Another person was found to have a thyroid ima artery that emerged from the brachiocephalic trunk.

Research conclusions

In our study, superior thyroid artery (STA) originated from external carotid artery in 77% of instances,and the common carotid artery (CCA) and common carotid bifurcation were the sources of STA in more than 22% of cases. Variation in the degree of CCA bifurcation was also observed, which significantly alters the path of STA. The current study shows that there is a 4% variance in inferior thyroid artery origin, whereas its course varies depending on the level of thyrocervical trunk origin. We discovered that the thyroid ima artery is only occasionally present in a small number of cases—it was only present in one case—and that if it goes unnoticed, it can cause serious hemorrhagic disease.

Research perspectives

The Garhwal region of the Sub-Himalayan belt, which is thought to be the endemic zone of goitre, has little scientific literature on the radiological anatomy of thyroid arteries. A three-dimensional orientation of the vascular and surgical anatomy of the entire cervical region is provided by computed tomography angiography. The objective of the current research was to examine the origin and variation of thyroid arteries, with the aid of Computed Tomography angiography, Surgeons must be familiar with the course and variations of the thyroid arteries to prevent difficulties during thyroid operations. Additional research in this area using even better methods can further add to the existing knowledge on thyroid arteries.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We would like to thank the attendants and fellows from the Radiology department of AIIMS Rishikesh as well as the laboratory staff, Mr. Devender, for their continued support and assistance during data collection.

FOOTNOTES

Author contributions:All the authors have contributed significantly to this work; Singh B, Bhadoria P and Malhotra R designed the research study; Bhardwaj Y and Tarafdar S performed the research; Bhardwaj Y, Malhotra R and Bisht K analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript; All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Institutional review board statement:Following the approval of Institutional Ethics Committee, with ethical clearance number AIIMS/IEC/21/323, CT angiographic data from 64-slice CT scanner and 128-slice CT scanner were collected from the Department of Radiodiagnosis.

Informed consent statement:A waiver was granted by our Institutional Ethics committee as this is a retrospective study.

Conflict-of-interest statement:The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Data sharing statement:Anonymization of data will be maintained.

Open-Access:This article is an open-access article that was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial (CC BYNC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is noncommercial. See: https://creativecommons.org/Licenses/by-nc/4.0/

Country/Territory of origin:India

ORCID number:Yashu Bhardwaj 0009-0008-0506-2899; Brijendra Singh 0000-0002-3501-0896; Pooja Bhadoria 0000-0001-9617-6526; Rashmi Malhotra 0000-0002-5633-5446; Swarnava Tarafdar 0000-0003-3582-8871; Kanchan Bisht 0000-0002-4615-1352.

S-Editor:Liu JH

L-Editor:A

P-Editor:Zhao S